{"@context":{"@vocab":"https://schema.org/"},"@type":"ItemList","@id":"https://api.morvs.ai/api/v1/msha/violations/check?name=Victor%20J%20Hirsch%20III","name":"Victor J Hirsch III","_source":{"data_provider":"AI Analytics","brand_name":"MORVS","brand_url":"https://morvs.ai/","data_provider_url":"https://api.morvs.ai","license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","primary_source":"https://arlweb.msha.gov/OpenGovernmentData/OGIMSHA.asp","generated_at":"2026-10-03T05:41:43.038Z"},"summary":{"total_violations":90,"significant_and_substantial":25,"proposed_penalty_usd":19101,"amount_paid_usd":14768},"top_violated_rules":[{"part_section":"50.30(a)","n":16},{"part_section":"56.9301","n":4},{"part_section":"56.9300(a)","n":4},{"part_section":"56.1000","n":4},{"part_section":"56.4201(a)(2)","n":3},{"part_section":"56.4101","n":3},{"part_section":"56.18010","n":3},{"part_section":"56.18002(a)","n":3},{"part_section":"56.14132(a)","n":3},{"part_section":"56.18002","n":2}],"recent_violations":[{"violation_no":"9643540","issue_date":"12/29/2021","mine_id":"4105550","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Materials","sig_sub":"Y","part_section":"56.14112(b)","negligence":"HighNegligence","proposed_penalty":481,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9643540"},{"violation_no":"9643541","issue_date":"12/29/2021","mine_id":"4105550","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Materials","sig_sub":"Y","part_section":"56.14112(b)","negligence":"HighNegligence","proposed_penalty":481,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9643541"},{"violation_no":"9643542","issue_date":"12/29/2021","mine_id":"4105550","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Materials","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.18010","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":133,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9643542"},{"violation_no":"9643543","issue_date":"12/29/2021","mine_id":"4105550","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Materials","sig_sub":"Y","part_section":"56.18002","negligence":"HighNegligence","proposed_penalty":481,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9643543"},{"violation_no":"9643544","issue_date":"12/29/2021","mine_id":"4105550","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Materials","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.20008(a)","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":133,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9643544"},{"violation_no":"9643545","issue_date":"12/29/2021","mine_id":"4105550","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Materials","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.12028","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":133,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9643545"},{"violation_no":"9456385","issue_date":"12/09/2019","mine_id":"4105258","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Crushing LLC","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"50.30(a)","negligence":"LowNegligence","proposed_penalty":123,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9456385"},{"violation_no":"9456383","issue_date":"12/03/2019","mine_id":"4105258","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Crushing LLC","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.9301","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":123,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9456383"},{"violation_no":"9643517","issue_date":"11/15/2021","mine_id":"4105402","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Crushing LLC","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.18010","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":125,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9643517"},{"violation_no":"9745151","issue_date":"11/14/2025","mine_id":"4105550","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Materials","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"46.9(a)","negligence":"HighNegligence","proposed_penalty":151,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9745151"},{"violation_no":"9745152","issue_date":"11/14/2025","mine_id":"4105550","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Materials","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"50.30(a)","negligence":"HighNegligence","proposed_penalty":165,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9745152"},{"violation_no":"9745153","issue_date":"11/14/2025","mine_id":"4105550","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Materials","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"50.30(a)","negligence":"HighNegligence","proposed_penalty":165,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9745153"},{"violation_no":"9745154","issue_date":"11/14/2025","mine_id":"4105550","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Materials","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"50.30(a)","negligence":"HighNegligence","proposed_penalty":165,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9745154"},{"violation_no":"9745155","issue_date":"11/14/2025","mine_id":"4105550","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Materials","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"50.30(a)","negligence":"HighNegligence","proposed_penalty":165,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9745155"},{"violation_no":"9745156","issue_date":"11/14/2025","mine_id":"4105550","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Materials","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"50.30(a)","negligence":"HighNegligence","proposed_penalty":151,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9745156"},{"violation_no":"9740532","issue_date":"11/13/2025","mine_id":"4105550","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Materials","sig_sub":"Y","part_section":"56.9300(a)","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":398,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9740532"},{"violation_no":"9745144","issue_date":"11/13/2025","mine_id":"4105550","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Materials","sig_sub":"Y","part_section":"46.11(c)","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":443,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9745144"},{"violation_no":"9745145","issue_date":"11/13/2025","mine_id":"4105550","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Materials","sig_sub":"Y","part_section":"56.3200","negligence":"HighNegligence","proposed_penalty":1320,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9745145"},{"violation_no":"9745146","issue_date":"11/13/2025","mine_id":"4105550","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Materials","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.12013(b)","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":151,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9745146"},{"violation_no":"9745147","issue_date":"11/13/2025","mine_id":"4105550","controller_name":"Victor J  Hirsch III","violator_name":"Primal Materials","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.12005","negligence":"HighNegligence","proposed_penalty":151,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9745147"}]}