ACTION FOR NPDES DISCHARGE VIOLATIONS FROM SIX MINES OWNED BY CONSOL ENERGY AND ITS SUBSIDIARIES IN NORTHERN WEST VIRGINIA. DISCHARGES OF UNDERGROUND MINE WATER FROM THESE MINES FREQUENTLY VIOLATED THE PERMIT LIMITS FOR CHLORIDE. THIS DISCHARGES OF TWO OF THE MINES, BLACKSVILLE 2 AND LOVERIDGE, VIOLATED THE NARRATIVE CRITERIA INCORPORATED IN THE PERMITS CONTRIBUTING TO THE FISH KILL IN DUNKARD CREEK IN LATE SUMMER OF 2009.