← EPA enforcement cases

HP PRODUCTS

Administrative - Formal · FY1995 · — · Final Order With Penalty · 29419

$3K
Penalty
Cost recovery
Compliance action

Case

Case Number
05-1995-0455
Type
Administrative - Formal
Lead
EPA
Outcome
Final Order With Penalty
Multimedia
N
Self-disclosure
N

Defendants (1)

Summary

SALE OF ADULTERATED PESTICIDE. RESPONDENT WAS ONE OF THREE COMPANIES SUED FOR SELLING THE IDENTICAL PRODUCTS. HP PRODUCTS CORP., WAS THE PRODUCER OF THE PESTICIDE PRODUCTS AT ISSUE; THE OTHER RESPONDENTS WERE THE DISTRIBUTOR AND THE STORE THAT SOLD THE PRODUCTS TO CUSTOMERS. RESPONDENT RAISED AS A DEFENSE THE ARGUMENT THAT EPA COULD NOT SEEK THE FULL PROPOSED PENALTY FOR THE SALE OF A GIVEN PRODUCT FROM ALL THREE RESPONDENTS, BECAUSE FIFRA DID NOT ALLOW FOR JOINT AND SEVERAL LIABILITY; RATHER, EPA HAD TO EITHER APPORTION THE PENALTY AMONG THE THREE RES- PONDENTS, OR SEEK COLLECTION FROM ONLY ONE. THE PENATY POLICY SEEMED AMBIGUOUS. HENCE, THE PROPOSED PENALTY WAS REDUCED FOR LITIGATION RISKS.

Source

Authoritative
EPA ECHO
Machine
JSON-LD · Markdown