# PHILBERT ARCHULETA, BARNEY CARANTA, RAY CHAVEZ, SANDRA CLAYP
> **Administrative - Formal** · FY1998 · — · Final Order No Penalty
## Case
- **Activity ID:** `37937`
- **Case Number:** 06-1998-0241
- **Type:** Administrative - Formal
- **Lead:** EPA
- **Outcome:** Final Order No Penalty
- **Penalty assessed:** —
- **Cost recovery:** —
- **Compliance action $:** —
- **Multimedia (multi-env):** N
## Defendants
- ADELA GOMEZ (complaint) (settlement)
- ALEX HERRERA, SR. (complaint) (settlement)
- ALFONSO VALDEZ (complaint) (settlement)
- ALFREDO TALAMANTE (complaint) (settlement)
- BARNEY CARANTA (complaint) (settlement)
- BILL EAKLOR (complaint) (settlement)
- BILL KENDRICK (complaint) (settlement)
- CHRIS LUCERO (complaint) (settlement)
- CHRIS TALAMANTE (complaint) (settlement)
- DAVID A. MITCHELL (complaint) (settlement)
- DAVID MONTOYA (complaint) (settlement)
- EL RANCHERO CAFE (complaint) (settlement)
- ELMA GARCIA (complaint) (settlement)
- EUGENE GOMEZ (complaint) (settlement)
- EUSTACIO VALDEZ (complaint) (settlement)
- FILIMON TALAMANTE (complaint) (settlement)
- FRANCES NUNO (complaint) (settlement)
- GOOD NEWS BAPTIST (complaint) (settlement)
- JOE TALAMANTE (complaint) (settlement)
- JOEY VALDEZ (complaint) (settlement)
- JOHN CARANTA (complaint) (settlement)
- JOHN TATOR (complaint) (settlement)
- JOSE MANUEL MONTOYA (complaint) (settlement)
- JULIAN MONTOYA (complaint) (settlement)
- LEONARD GONZALES (complaint) (settlement)
- LOLLIE PALMER (complaint) (settlement)
- LUIS MARTINEZ (complaint) (settlement)
- LUPITA GOMEZ (complaint) (settlement)
- M. HAMED JEBBANEMA (complaint) (settlement)
- MANUELITA MERCURE (complaint) (settlement)
- MARINO TALAMANTE (complaint) (settlement)
- MARK MARQUEZ (complaint) (settlement)
- MARYJANE MESTAS (complaint) (settlement)
- MICHAEL GOMEZ (complaint) (settlement)
- MICHAEL J. CORDOVA (complaint) (settlement)
- PHILBERT ARCHULETA (complaint) (settlement)
- RAMON MARTINEZ (complaint) (settlement)
- RAMONA MARES (complaint) (settlement)
- RAY CHAVEZ (complaint) (settlement)
- RAY TAFOYA (complaint) (settlement)
- RAY TALAMANTE (complaint) (settlement)
- ROBERT MONTOYA (complaint) (settlement)
- ROSIE VALDEZ (complaint) (settlement)
- SANDRA CLAYPOOL (complaint) (settlement)
- VERNA SHERWOOD (complaint) (settlement)
- YOLANDA MARES (complaint) (settlement)
## Summary

1. SECTION 1414(G) OF THE SAFE DRINKING WATER ACT ( SDWA ),     42 U.S.C. SECTION 300G-3(G).                              2. LUMBERTON WATER SYSTEM                                       #20 C/R 3970                                                 LUMBERTON, RIO ARRIBA COUNTY, NEW MEXICO 87547            3. RESPONDENTS WERE IN VIOLATION OF SECTION 1412 OF THE SDWA    BY 1) FAILING TO COLLECT SUCH ROUTINE TOTAL COLIFORM SAM-    PLES AND FAILING TO CONDUCT SUCH ANALYSIS, AND 2) FAILING    TO COLLECT REPEAT TOTAL COLIFORM SAMPLES AND CONDUCT RE-     PEAT TOTAL COLIFORM ANALYSES WITHIN 24 HOURS OF BEING NO-    TIFIED OF A POSITIVE TOTAL COLIFORM ANALYSIS.             4. RELIEF SOUGHT PURSUANT TO SECTION 1414(G) OF THE SDWA,       EPA ISSUED AN ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER (AO) REQUIRING THE RE-    SPONDENT TO: A) UPON RECEIPT OF THE AO, COLLECT ROUTINE      TOTAL COLIFORM SAMPLES AT SITES WHICH ARE REPRESENTATIVE     OF WATER THROUGHOUT THE DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM AND TO CON-      DUCT TOTAL COLIFORM ANALYSES, AND 2) UPON RECEIPT OF THE     AO, COLLECT REPEAT TOTAL COLIFORM SAMPLES AND CONDUCT RE-    PEAT TOTAL COLIFORM ANALYSES WITHIN 24 HOURS OF BEING NO-    TIFIED OF A POSITIVE COLIFORM ANALYSIS.

---
*Source: [EPA ECHO](https://echo.epa.gov/) · AI Analytics · CC0 1.0*