PsyRAT: Extensible Open-Source Software for Applying Generalizability Theory to Assess Psychometric Reliability of Trial-Wise Scores and Optimize Tasks for RDoC

NIH RePORTER · NIH · R01 · $576,175 · view on reporter.nih.gov ↗

Abstract

PROJECT SUMMARY/ABSTRACT Neural biomarkers are an important focus of the NIMH Research Domain Criteria (RDoC) initiative, and they are increasingly used in the context of genomic studies and clinical trials. The use of biomarkers with strong psychometric reliability increases the likelihood of finding replicable effects, improves the validity of their interpretation, and decreases the likelihood of missing real phenomena. Although fundamental psychometric principles have long been a prominent concern among studies that use self-report measures, these principles are underappreciated in studies of psychopathology that use biological measures. This lack of attention to reliability limits the more widespread application of biomarkers in psychopathology and likely contributes to replication problems. Generalizability theory is a multifaceted framework for identifying sources of measurement error, and this framework is uniquely suited to assessing the reliability of biological measures and to optimizing tasks for reliability. A critical need exists for tractable software to facilitate the application of generalizability theory to time-frequency electroencephalography (EEG), event-related potentials (ERPs), facial electromyography (EMG), and electrodermal activity (EDA). The objective of this project in response to PAR- 18-930 on measurement tool development for RDoC is to (i) develop an extensive treatment of generalizability theory for psychopathology researchers, (ii) develop accessible software to implement it, (iii) show how to apply these resources to optimize paradigms for individual-differences research, and (iv) disseminate the software with a user-friendly guide. This project will facilitate the routine evaluation of reliability through these specific aims: 1) Design and implement generalizability theory formulas for evaluating group- and subject-level reliability for paradigm optimization; 2) Develop software to implement these formulas with data from widely used psychophysiological software; 3) Apply results to optimize three commonly studied tasks; and 4) Develop online educational material on the application of these resources to novel paradigms and measures. This research project is innovative, because it represents a substantive departure from standard practice by shifting the focus to the reliability of data from individuals, rather than groups, to identify sources of measurement error and minimize their impact. This work promotes best practices in reporting psychometric properties of biological measures and is applicable to data from any task with trial-wise scores. The resulting open-source toolbox, the Psychophysiologist’s Reliability Analysis Toolbox (PsyRAT), can facilitate guidelines for optimizing paradigms, making decisions about individual-subject data, and grounding individual-differences questions (central to clinical research, especially for applications in precision medicine) in measures of reliability. The proposed process...

Key facts

NIH application ID
10676972
Project number
5R01MH128208-02
Recipient
UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH FLORIDA
Principal Investigator
Peter Eugene Clayson
Activity code
R01
Funding institute
NIH
Fiscal year
2023
Award amount
$576,175
Award type
5
Project period
2022-08-04 → 2027-06-30