# MSHA citation `6454479`
> **Significant & Substantial** · Citation · 11/18/2009 · Alberto Ayala
## Rule
- **Section of Act:** —
- **Part / Section:** 56.15004
- **Type:** Citation
## Severity
- **S&S flag:** Y
- **Likelihood:** Reasonably
- **Injury/Illness:** Permanent
- **# affected:** 1
- **Negligence:** ModNegligence
## Money
- **Proposed penalty:** $108
- **Amount paid:** $108
- **Amount due:** $108
- **Contested:** N
## Parties
- **Mine:** [0203239](https://api.ai-analytics.org/mine/0203239) — Ayala John Brown
- **Violator:** Alberto Ayala (Operator)
- **Controller:** Alberto (Ayala)  Millan
---
*Source: [MSHA Open Government Data](https://arlweb.msha.gov/OpenGovernmentData/) · AI Analytics · CC0 1.0*